Give to Caesar what belongs to Caesar
and to God what belongs to God.
Matthew 22
Even
though the gospel today is about the relationship of “church and state” loosely, I know better than
mention American politics in today’s explosive climate. I do, however, have a
little history lesson for those of you who are quite a bit younger than me. It
has to do with an important Kentucky “church and state” court decision that I lived through as a child.
While I
was in the fifth grade, around 1955 I believe, our parish Catholic school
became a public school. The nuns who taught us stayed on as teachers, but since
their salaries came from the public school system and we have the separation of
church and state in this country, the courts said that we could no longer be a
religious school if we wanted to keep getting state tax funds. The court case
actually came from a case involving one of the parishes in central Kentucky where
I was pastor before I came here in 1983.
Overnight we
changed our name from Saint Theresa School to Cross Roads School. The nuns had
to quit teaching religion, making religious references and remove all religious
symbols from the building. They were allowed to keep wearing their religious
habits and were actually paid a salary by the county. Even though we officially
became “Cross Roads School,” “Saint Theresa School” which remained chiseled in
stone over the doors” was never removed. It remains there today even though the
school has long since closed.
We
were allowed, for several years after that, to be released one hour a week to
go to the church next door for religious instructions. Religious instruction
had to be optional and held off site.
This
arrangement had its benefits: the parish did not have to come up with the money
to pay teachers, we still got religious instruction and the county paid the
Sisters of Charity rent on the school building since they owned it. Even though
this change had its benefits, it was painful. I can still remember the day that
I saw one of the nuns standing by the water fountain as the janitor took the
big crucifix down and handed it to her to be taken away. That day, at the age
of ten, I learned my first life lesson on the advantages and disadvantages of
the separation of church and state.
Today’s
Scripture passage is about the relationship between faith life and civil
life. Jesus and his followers were Jews
living in a country occupied by the Roman Empire. Their religion was tolerated
by the Roman government, but they were obliged to pay taxes to the Roman Emperor.
The Jewish people resented paying civil taxes because they wanted to be a
Jewish state with God as their king.
Taxes and control were sore spots for the Roman government, as well as for the
Jewish people. This delicate balance was always in danger of boiling over into
conflict, just as it is today. There are always “church and state issues”
before the Supreme Court: prayer in public schools, religious symbols and words
on state and federal property and a host of other issues.
It
was in this volatile environment that Jesus was confronted with a loaded
question. The question sounds harmless on the surface, “Is it lawful to pay
taxes to Caesar or not?,” but it was a cleverly framed question to embarrass
Jesus in front of his fans, a trick question to trap Jesus in his speech. It was get-even time for his critics, or at
least they thought.
If
Jesus said that it was OK to pay taxes to Rome, those who wanted a
Jewish state would turn against him. If Jesus said it was not OK to pay taxes
to Rome, the Roman government would arrest him and take him to jail. Jesus
outwitted them with his wise and insightful answer, “Give to Caesar what is
Caesar’s and give to God what is God’s.” The first Letter of Peter puts it this
way, “Fear God. Honor the emperor.”
This
advice is as good today as it was then. Every Christian has dual citizenship.
He is a citizen of the country in which he lives and he is also a citizen of
heaven. There are times when the state
ought to stay out of church matters and there are times when the church ought
to stay out of state matters.
It
was a tricky balance then. It is a tricky balance now. History teaches us that
we have run off both sides of the road. There are disaster stories where
governments have made religion illegal and just as many, if not more, disaster
stories of religions taking over government. Even in a country like ours, the
United Sates Bishops’ Conference has a whole Committee on Religious Liberty,
because they think the government is infringing on the rights of religion and
we have others, like President Ronald Reagan’s son in his “freedom from
religion” TV ad, who think that our government should be totally free from religious
intrusions.
History,
I believe, has taught us the wisdom of the separation of church and state. As
fragile as it is, it is the only way religious freedom can be insured for the
masses who hold a variety of religious beliefs.
Our own constitutional principle of the separation of church and state
guarantees freedom of religion as
well as freedom from
religion. Believers are free to practice their religion and non-believers are just
as free not to practice any religion, if they choose. It is a good arrangement,
an arrangement that seems to work, even if not perfectly, in today’s multi-cultural, multi-ethnic and
multi-religion world, something I would hope both secular humanists and the
Christian right remember in their power struggle.
As
Catholics, we need to be reminded, from time to time, that we have been both perpetrators,
as well as victims, when it comes to religious freedom. At times and in places,
we have forced our religion on to others. Other times, as in the early days of this
country, there were many places in the Colonies where we were not allowed to openly
practice our religion. As Catholics, we need to remember as well that our faith
has been strongest when we have been under persecution and weakest when we have
been in the privileged position.