FATHER WHO? FATHER WHAT? FATHER WHEN? FATHER WHY? FATHER HOW?
This year is the 55th anniversary of my First Mass at St. Theresa Church down in Rhodelia, Kentucky. I thought it might be a good opportunity to recall some of my favorite situations where my priesthood was called into question. Almost all of them took place in my first 10 years when I was stationed down along the Tennessee border where Catholics make it one-tenth of one percent of the population.
Disapproval for what I had become came very soon after my ordination. At one of the receptions, either after my ordination or after my First Mass, I was confronted by a young woman who asked how many years I had gone to school to be a priest. When I answered, "Counting eight years of grade school, four years of high school, four years of college and four years of theology studies, I guess you could say twenty years altogether!" She took a step back and responded, "My God, you could have been something!" Obviously, she was thinking "doctor" or "lawyer" or "scientist" - the professions that really "count?"
----
Not too long after I arrived in the southern part of the state, I went to a barbershop to get a haircut. It was my day off and I was dressed "down" as they say. Like most people in that area, he was curious about this stranger sitting in his barber chair. It didn't take him long to ask the "big" question, "What do you do? I took a deep breath and answered "Catholic priest." He was obviously taking his time thinking about how to respond. Then he asked his second question which surprised me. Instead of questioning me about why I was Catholic, he asked, "Was your father a priest too?" Obviously, he knew very little about "priests" so I decided to give him my short answer. I simply said, "Oh, I hope not!" He didn't "get it" so we moved on to other topics, leaving him still trying to understand what I just said!
----
Not too long after I settled in the the southern part of the state, I took 12-15 young adults from the parish to one of the Lake Cumberland's local beaches. As we got in and out of the water and interacted with each other, the young adults were calling "Father this" and Father that!" Not being used to having priests in that area, this caused a woman not far away to come over and ask about the young adults who were calling me "Father," "Excuse me sir, but you look very young! Just how many kids do you have, anyway?"
----
In a few years down there, I volunteered to do some campus ministry at Somerset Community College. I was probably reaching more non-Catholic students than Catholic students. Once in a while, they would come by the rectory and ring the doorbell looking for me. One day, one of them came by and rang the doorbell. Instead of me, answering the door, the other associate pastor answered. This caused the young man who came looking for me to panic. He had a momentary lapse of memory and in his panic, he could not recall my name "Father Knott." Instead, he asked to see "Father Bump!"
----
So many of the students down there had grown up with Protestant warnings about Matthew 23:9 that said you should "call no one your father." They were comfortable calling their male parents "father," but they were reluctant to call a Catholic priest "Father." As I result, I was given the nickname "Pad," which is short for "Padre!" To this day, over 55 years later, some of the people down in that area of the state still address me in their Christmas cards and texts "Pad." Others addressed me as "Reverend," "Brother" or "Preacher."