Thursday, November 19, 2026

A PARADIGM SHIFT AS AN ALTERNATIVE TO PARISH CLOSINGS?

 

A "PARADIGM SHIFT" IS "A NEW WAY OF ORGANIZING AN OLD REALITY" 

To all those "traditional" Catholics who yearn for the "good old days," I say this! "Be careful what you pray for, but I also say bring it on!" Yes, let's solve our "priest shortage" by bringing back our own old paradigm for how our parishes might be served today.  In the "good old days" of our diocese, lay people ran our parishes and priests moved around! That makes more sense to me for expanding our mission than shrinking it by closing parishes that are operating pretty well as they are! After all, we went back to our old paradigm when we started accepting "foreign born" priests again as a solution to our present "priest shortage." In our very own old paradigm, most of our priests were foreign born - even our first bishop! Many of them had to learn English after they got here!  

Buried in St. Louis Cemetery, maybe one mile from my condo, are a few of our early pastors. Father Elisha John Durbin, so says his tombstone, rode 500,000 miles on horse back taking care of lay-led Catholic communities all over western Kentucky, parts of southern Illinois, southern Indiana and northern Tennessee. Father Durbin's missionary travels included stops at my home parish of St. Theresa of Avila in Rhodelia established in 1818 -- 208 years ago! He was only one of several missionary priests buried there who served our many far-flung lay-led Catholic communities on the frontier when we were still part of the Diocese of Baltimore and in the early days of our own Diocese of Bardstown.  

We have many more resources than they had back then, but we have much less imagination, determination and probably faith - not to mention a dramatic increase in lay education! Today, implementing this old paradigm might require that we use one of our local Catholic universities or seminaries to offer degrees for training lay people to be parish administrators and degrees training priests in the area of parish revitalization.  Who said that we only get one "golden age?" Why not a few more "golden ages?" I, for one, believe that our lack of imagination is what is mainly holding us back! 

To do this, we would also need to (a) partner more with other denominations to share existing under-used facilities, (b) give old properties away to others who can carry on our mission in areas that we can no longer serve - like we did with our Christ the King parish property when we gave it to a black college in one of our under-served areas and (c) imagine totally new ways to carry on social services to struggling communities beyond religious services.  We need to think of new ways to expand our mission, not think of new ways to shrink our mission!  As I have said many times, and witnessed it personally many more times: "The biggest shortage in the Catholic Church is not priests or money, but imagination!" We need to either recover our old paradigm from when we had a much bigger shortage of priests than today or create new paradigms for the realities we now face! Either way, shrinking our mission to fit a worn-out paradigm should never be an option for us!    

The role of chanceries, and many governments in general, is to protect the present paradigm and give it life-support wherever possible. They seldom advocate for new paradigms that present dramatic changes for becoming "unstuck" and for going forward. Advocating for new paradigms is our job! Ideas for real change do not usually come from the top down! Ideas for effective change often comes from people at the bottom pushing their ideas up to the top! 

Go ahead! Don't wait for permission! Push your ideas up to the top and demand to be heard! One of the advantages of starting my own blog called "An Encouraging Word," after I stopped my fifteen-year weekly column in The Record also called "An Encouraging Word," is that I am freer now to share my ideas without fear of editing. What can they do to a retired priest like me for sharing my ideas on my own blog? Fire me?   



 


No comments:

Post a Comment